By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
Biden familyBiden family
  • White House Watch
    White House WatchShow More
    Trump hooks new works of art featuring in the White House
    3 weeks ago
    Video: Reporter describes a stormy argument between musk and besing in the white house
    3 weeks ago
    Restore equality of opportunities and meritocracy – the White House
    3 weeks ago
    The White House accuses Fed of doing politics
    3 weeks ago
    The White House reacts to countries that issued travel warnings for us
    3 weeks ago
  • US Elections
    US ElectionsShow More
    Trump Last: Carney says that King Charles will go to Canada this month – and confirm that he will visit Trump | US News
    2 weeks ago
    The Canada’s election day, Trump repeats the threat of the 51st state
    2 weeks ago
    2024 voting and registration tables of presidential elections now available
    2 weeks ago
    2 Ukrainian nationals responsible for illegally voting in the American elections 2024
    2 weeks ago
    Outlook Indiakamala Harris accuses Trump of “the abandonment of America” ​​in the first speech since the American vice-president of the presidential elections, Kamala Harris, accused Donald Trump of having abandoned the American ideals in his first major speech since 2024 … 7 hours ago
    2 weeks ago
  • Global Politics
    Global PoliticsShow More
    This Week in Review | Trump’s First 100 Days, US & Eurozone GDP, Global Politics (May 5, 2025) | Insights
    1 week ago
    Global politics are unfolding in ways that hark to 20th-century world wars [letter] | Letters To The Editor
    2 weeks ago
    Revisiting Trust and Mistrust in Global Politics / UConn Calendar
    2 weeks ago
    Handling New World Screwworm Amidst Global Politics
    2 weeks ago
    Resolution to block Trump’s global tariffs voted down by Senate | News
    2 weeks ago
  • What to Watch
    What to WatchShow More
    ಅಚ್ಚರಿ ಮತ್ತು ಮೂಡಿಸಿದ ಮೂಡಿಸಿದ ರಾಹುಲ್ ಹೇಳಿಕೆ. ಮೋದಿಯವರು ಕೂಡ ಹೀಗೇ ಯೋಚಿಸಲಿ Rahul Gandhi
    2 weeks ago
    వై ఎస్ షర్మిల అరెస్ట్ అరెస్ట్ … | Sreleela political analyst on the resistance of YS Sharmila houses | AP news
    2 weeks ago
    Farage supports Luke Campbell to deliver a political uppercut to the elections of the mayor of Hull
    1 month ago
    The Republicans adopted the draft law on the abolition of voters in the name of election security.
    1 month ago
    放話 → 恐嚇 → 逼談判! 川普 “以商弄政” 搞亂天下│主播 苑曉琬│大世界新聞 20250410│三立 inews
    1 month ago
  • First Family
    First FamilyShow More
    The impeachment inquiry against Joe Biden was doomed from the start
    1 year ago
    Joe Biden Shares He Once Considered Suicide After the Deaths of His First Wife and Infant Daughter
    1 year ago
    Joe Biden tells Howard Stern he considered suicide after his family died
    1 year ago
    Joe Biden contemplated suicide after the deaths of his wife and young daughter
    1 year ago
    Biden contemplated suicide after the deaths of his first wife and daughter
    1 year ago
  • Political Trends
    Political TrendsShow More
    Donald Trump’s big electoral victory is part of a major global trend
    6 months ago
    Yale presents course on Beyoncé’s political and cultural impact
    6 months ago
    Trump wins in Maryland: a trend or an aberration?
    6 months ago
    The New York Times Kamala Harris vs. Donald Trump: Latest Polls on the 2024 Presidential Election Our polling averages track the latest trends in the presidential race, using data from national and battleground state polls. 2 days away
    6 months ago
    Live results from the 2024 presidential election: Donald Trump wins
    6 months ago
  • Politics
    PoliticsShow More
    New York repeals call for U.S. constitutional convention
    1 year ago
    Democrats Prepare Aggressive Counter to Third-Party Threats
    1 year ago
    Biden’s state-of-the-union | Latest US politics news from The Economist
    1 year ago
    Biden Promised Calm After Trump Chaos, but the World Has Not Cooperated
    1 year ago
    Bracing for a Trump Rematch, Biden Confronts Four Thorny Challenges
    1 year ago
Reading: Delhi Air Pollution And Global Climate Policy Slowdown
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
Biden familyBiden family
Font ResizerAa
  • White House Watch
  • US Elections
  • Global Politics
  • What to Watch
  • First Family
  • Political Trends
  • Politics
  • White House Watch
  • US Elections
  • Global Politics
  • What to Watch
  • First Family
  • Political Trends
  • Politics
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
Biden family > Blog > Global Politics > Delhi Air Pollution And Global Climate Policy Slowdown
Global Politics

Delhi Air Pollution And Global Climate Policy Slowdown

fv99w
Last updated: 2023/11/13 at 10:20 AM
fv99w 2 years ago
Share
1699870818 0x0.jpg
SHARE

TOPSHOT – People walk along the Kartavya Path near India Gate amid heavy smog conditions in New … [+] Delhi on November 3, 2023. (Photo by ARUN THAKUR/AFP via Getty Images)

AFP via Getty Images

If a policy imposes costs locally to create benefits across the border, it is likely to run into local opposition. This is the story of Delhi’s air pollution as well as the global slowdown in addressing climate issues.

Every October-November, New Delhi, India’s capital, experiences severe air pollution due to stubble burning in neighboring states, particularly Punjab. After harvesting paddy (a monsoon crop), farmers want to prepare their fields for wheat, a winter crop. But this requires removing paddy stubble, which they simply burn. This causes air pollution in Delhi, so severe that schools are closed. By some estimates, this pollution episode reduces Delhi’s gross state product by 1%.

One might wonder why this egregious pollution problem cannot be solved. Surely technology is available in a country that has sent a spaceship to the Moon and is becoming a global hub for high-tech manufacturing. Moreover, India’s global political ambitions should motivate the government to address this issue.

Technology is indeed available to address stubble burning. Haryana, Punjab’s neighboring state, has been largely able to control the burning issue. Moreover, Punjab has laws banning stubble burning and India’s Supreme Court has instructed it to enforce them. The same political party, the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), rules both Delhi (the pollution recipient) and Punjab (the major pollution creator), and this should create political incentives for enforcing the law.

So, what’s missing? Enforcing the law means inviting the wrath of the powerful constituency, Sikh farmers. Given the history of violent unrest in Punjab, this enforcement action could become a sectarian issue. This is probably why previous governments ruled by other parties chose not to enforce the burning ban either.

What about the citizens of Delhi? Are they not angry with AAP? Apparently not because AAP won the 2022 local elections. This suggests that pollution concerns are not high salience issue in Indian politics.

Could financial incentives stop stubble burning? For example, farmers could be provided subsidized machines (such as the happy seeder machine to cut the straw and distribute it as mulch on the field). In terms of ex situ measures, the government could subsidize the transportation of straw to local power plants to be used as fuel with appropriate pollution safeguards. All these measures require money, and the Punjab government is facing a budgetary crisis. So, it blames the Central government for not providing it with funds. And the Central government with its highly acrimonious relationship with the AAP feels no need to bail them out. Moreover, if Haryana could address the issue on its own, why not Punjab?

Climate Progress or Climate Sluggishness?

The burning ban reflects the spatial mismatch between the costs and the benefits of policy action. Might the same logic explain the global slowdown in climate policy?

The recent United Nations Environmental Programme’s (UNEP) Production Gap Report suggests that major fossil fuel-producing countries will probably extract more than twice the amount of fossil fuels by 2030 than what is consistent with 1.5 degrees Celsius target, and around 70 percent more than the amount consistent with the 2 degrees Celsius target.

The reasons are several, ranging from continued demand for oil (primarily in the transportation sector) to the attractiveness of coal (often a domestically available fuel) for energy security reasons. Without cheap fossil fuels, there is economic unrest, and this creates political problems. So governments want to avoid policies restricting fossil fuels because they impose local costs to create the global public good of climate mitigation.

What then is the way forward?

Many climate technologies are now cost-competitive (sometimes due to subsidies) but their uptake is slower than anticipated. Again, the local-global tension is in play.

Some recent setbacks are due to rising interest rates. Orsted has taken a $4 billion write-off and canceled two large offshore wind projects in New Jersey. NuScale Power, a small modular reactor pioneer, has canceled its Idaho project because rising interest rates and project overruns have increased the project cost to $9.3 billion from $5.3 billion.

Yet, solar and one-shore wind do not seem to be facing similar cost issues. For them, the challenge is political: the pushback from local groups along with regulatory bottlenecks in creating transmission capacity. Rural residents are opposing solar and wind farms–by some estimates, about 24% of US counties have enacted laws in this regard. And proposals for streamlining regulatory approval for new power lines provoke opposition from local groups as well.

The bottom line is that tackling Delhi’s air pollution or addressing slowdown in climate policy requires resolving the tension between local costs and non-local benefits. Technology and policy tools are available to resolve this tension such as increasing subsidies for new technologies, regulatory overhaul, and enforcing the law. But these strategies impose political costs, which policy makers are not willing to incur. Moral appeals about the health impact of pollution or invoking a new UN report about the direness of the climate crisis are not working. Perhaps, an even stronger financial commitment to support climate action is required. But this requires prioritizing climate issues over other pressing social problems. Does the political class have the will to do so?

You Might Also Like

This Week in Review | Trump’s First 100 Days, US & Eurozone GDP, Global Politics (May 5, 2025) | Insights

Global politics are unfolding in ways that hark to 20th-century world wars [letter] | Letters To The Editor

Revisiting Trust and Mistrust in Global Politics / UConn Calendar

Handling New World Screwworm Amidst Global Politics

Resolution to block Trump’s global tariffs voted down by Senate | News

fv99w November 13, 2023 November 13, 2023
Share This Article
Facebook Twitter Email Print
Previous Article Fnchd Hannity 2023 11 09 09 00 00 Pm 2.jpg Fox News’ Newt Gingrich Compares Biden Family to The Sopranos
Next Article Ap23278782196568 1696543399 E1696569749904.jpg ‘Dysfunctional’: Speaker debacle plunges US politics into uncertainty | Politics News
Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!

Main Menu

  • White House Watch
  • US Elections
  • Global Politics
  • What to Watch
  • First Family
  • Political Trends
  • Politics

Quick links

  • Home
  • Contact us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of service

Categories

  • First Family327
  • Global Politics775
  • Political Trends265
  • Politics357
  • Uncategorized1
  • US Elections788
  • What to Watch1,983
  • White House Watch634
© biden.family All Rights Reserved.
Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts etc..

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?